Auditors ✓ Lawyers ✓ Tax advisors ✓ and business consultants ✓ : Four perspectives. One solution. Worldwide. Learn …
Auditing and audit-related advice for companies ✓ Experienced auditors ✓ Excellent advice ✓ Tailor-made solutions » …
Our clients entrust us with their most important legal matters. Learn more about our legal services!
Tax laws are complex and dynamic. We face the challenge of tax law together with you - find out more.
Business consulting for companies ✓ Experienced consultants ✓ Excellent advice ✓ Tailor-made solutions » more
Failed Delivery of a Notice of Termination: No Fresh Works Council Consultation Required
Dismissal Protection for Managing Directors: Federal Labour Court Clarifies the Order of Removal and Termination
Online Notarization Expanded: GmbH Share Transfers and Stock Corporation Formations to Go Digital
Bafin Publishes WpI MaRisk: New Supervisory Framework for Small and Medium Investment Firms
EmpCo Directive: New Requirements for Environmental Claims Apply from September
Baker Tilly Advises SEVEST on Acquisition of Majority Stake in IBG HydroTech
Management buyout (MBO): Succession from within
E-Invoicing: German Ministry of Finance Clarifies Requirements and Addresses Practical Questions
Medical Supply Retailers (Sanitätshäuser): Tax and Accounting Pitfalls, and What the 3% Reduction Changes Starting in 2027
ICT risks when using AI: New BaFin guidance
One year of DORA: What's next for financial companies
Survey: Two thirds of German automotive suppliers anticipate a market shakeout
Cross-industry expertise for individual solutions ✓ Our interdisciplinary teams combine expertise & market …
Baker Tilly advises CERTANIA on the Acquisition of InnoDiab
New SGEI Decision: Key Changes at a Glance
SGEI Decision: New Funding Opportunities for Affordable Housing
Risk management ✓ Compliance and controls ✓ Increase and ensure security & conformity ✓ more»
Baker Tilly offers a wide range of individual and innovative consulting services. Find out more!
If delivery of a notice of termination fails, must the employer consult the works council again before trying a second time? The Regional Labor Court of Baden-Württemberg says no.
A security company decided to dismiss an employee during his probationary period and consulted the works council on May 12, 2025. The only reason it gave was that continuing the employment relationship was not in its interest. The works council did not respond.
On May 24, 2025, the company sent the notice of termination by courier. Both delivery attempts failed because the courier could not reach the mailboxes in the building’s hallway. The employee, as he had informed the employer, was then in hospital from May 25 to June 4, 2025. As the courier never returned the original letter, the employer issued a new notice of termination dated June 4, 2025 and handed it to the employee in person on June 10, 2025. It did not consult the works council again.
The Labor Court (Arbeitsgericht, ArbG) of Mannheim held the dismissal invalid for lack of a fresh consultation. In its view, a new consultation would have been unnecessary only if the works council had previously given its unconditional consent. It had not.
The Regional Labor Court (Landesarbeitsgericht, LAG) of Baden-Württemberg disagreed and held the dismissal valid. In its view, no fresh consultation under Section 102(1) sentence 3 of the Works Constitution Act (Betriebsverfassungsgesetz, BetrVG) was required. The court acknowledged that, under the case law of the Federal Labor Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht, BAG), a consultation procedure must in principle precede every dismissal. This applies in particular where a notice of termination has already been received following consultation: if the employer then wishes to issue a further dismissal, it must consult the works council again.
The position is different where the first notice was never received. A dismissal takes effect only upon receipt. Until then, the employer has not yet implemented its decision to dismiss; the new letter implements it for the first time. The original consultation is therefore not exhausted, provided there is a close temporal connection and the dismissal is based on the same facts. Both conditions were met here: the letter was identical in content and reached the employee within one week of his discharge from hospital.
Nor is express or unconditional consent from the works council required. Once the consultation procedure has been properly completed, the employer is entitled to issue the intended dismissal. Consultation is merely intended to give the works council an opportunity to present its view and, where appropriate, to influence the employer’s decision. The LAG thus expressly rejected the Labor Court’s reading of existing BAG case law.
An appeal on points of law (Revision) is pending before the BAG (Case No. 2 AZR 156/26).
The LAG’s reasoning is persuasive. In the cases the BAG has decided to date, the first notice of termination had already been received; in those cases, the BAG required a fresh consultation even for a mere repeat dismissal (Wiederholungskündigung). The judgment therefore sits comfortably with existing case law: in legal terms, the “second“ dismissal here was in fact the first. Comparable cases should nonetheless always be assessed on their individual facts.
Our recommendation: Until the BAG rules, employers should consult the works council again as a precaution unless it has already given its unconditional consent to the dismissal.
Questions about works council consultation or serving notices of termination? Please get in touch. Our Employment Law team is here to help.
Ralf Pelz
Manager
Attorney-at-Law (Rechtsanwalt)
Talk to us. Simply without obligation
Get in touch
View all news
Help us improve this page.
Please select at least one of the following statements: