Auditors ✓ Lawyers ✓ Tax advisors ✓ and business consultants ✓ : Four perspectives. One solution. Worldwide. Learn …
Auditing and audit-related advice for companies ✓ Experienced auditors ✓ Excellent advice ✓ Tailor-made solutions » …
Our clients entrust us with their most important legal matters. Learn more about our legal services!
Tax laws are complex and dynamic. We face the challenge of tax law together with you - find out more.
Business consulting for companies ✓ Experienced consultants ✓ Excellent advice ✓ Tailor-made solutions » more
In-house or outsourcing? Strategic decisions in accounting
Avoid shareholder conflicts: Structure instead of ambiguity
How far can the rights of a criminal defense insurer extend?
EU “Omnibus” Package: Less effort for sustainability reporting?
Baker Tilly starts the year 2025 with 23 new Directors
Challenges in corporate finance: Baker Tilly at Structured FINANCE 2024
Pay slips are purely information documents
Financing and funding: realignment in the coalition agreement
Accounting in corporate groups: Standardized structures instead of isolated solutions
Survey: Two thirds of German automotive suppliers anticipate a market shakeout
NIS-2 and no end in sight: implementation in Germany delayed further
Public procurement: Legally compliant procurement of cyber insurance
Cross-industry expertise for individual solutions ✓ Our interdisciplinary teams combine expertise & market …
Baker Tilly advises biotech startup Real Collagen GmbH investment by US investor
Energy study: Uncertainty slows down investments by industry and utilities in Germany
Risk management ✓ Compliance and controls ✓ Increase and ensure security & conformity ✓ more»
Baker Tilly offers a wide range of individual and innovative consulting services. Find out more!
On October 17, 2023, the Baker Tilly team (foreign trade and customs law) obtained a landmark ruling at the German Federal Tax Court regarding procedural interest for refunded import VAT.
In April 2016, the Hamburg Main Customs Office (“HZA”) levied additional import VAT on the plaintiff and defendant in the appeal, which related to import transactions from 2014. After this subsequent collection was declared unlawful in the fiscal court proceedings and reimbursed by the HZA, the plaintiff and defendant in the appeal applied for interest on refund amounts during legal proceedings (“procedural interest”) in accordance with Art. 236 AO (German General Tax Code). The HZA rejected the payment of procedural interest with reference to Art. 116 (6) UCC.
The German Federal Tax Court (“BFH”) confirms the first-instance decision and clarifies that Art. 241 UCC is applicable to all transactions where the customs debt was incurred before May 1, 2016. Contrary to the customs administration’s opinion, the action’s lis pendens is not relevant. Therefore, the claim to procedural interest in these cases cannot be precluded by Art. 116 UCC.
Following its success before the ECJ, the Baker Tilly team (foreign trade and customs law) was thus once again able to obtain a landmark decision on the issue of interest on refunds by the customs authorities. Baker Tilly lawyer Sven Pohl: “The BFH’s decision is not only correct in terms of content, it is also stringent, logical and very comprehensible. It is likely to be relevant for many other proceedings.”
Ruling leaves one question unanswered
The BFH does not comment on the question of whether procedural interest is also payable on customs debts incurred after May 1, 2016 in accordance with Art. 236 AO or whether this is precluded by Art. 116 (6) UCC, as this was not relevant to the decision in this case. In order to avoid further legal disputes, a reference by the BFH would have been desirable.
Sven Pohl
Director
Attorney-at-Law (Rechtsanwalt)
Contact now
Contact us
View all news